In November 2007 the
Dutch government declared efforts to come to adoption of a European
catch all policy was not needed, because “the idea of catch-all
is already implemented in all EU member states participating in the
Australia Group, the Missile Controle Regime, the Nuclear Suppliers
Group, the Wassenaar Arrangement and in Regulation EC/1334/2000 to
set-up a Community regime for the control of exports of dual-use each
containing a catch-all measurement.”(1) The Catch-all order is
based on Article 4 of this regulation.(2) It gives the government the
possibility to control items not on the control lists if there are
reasons to do so in circumstances as determined in article 4 of the
Dual-use regulation. Since the imposition of a catch-all provision
may lead to diminished legal certainty, the government uses its power
to impose a mandatory license requirement with great prudence and
caution.
It's use is specified
in the User Guide for Export Control on Strategic Goods and Services
and this states the catch all can be imposed on goods that are not
subject to mandatory licensing, but may be intended for:
* the development of
weapons of mass destruction or missiles capable of delivering such
weapons;
* may be intended for
goods on the EU list of military goods that have been exported to the
country of end-use without the proper license required (see article
4, paragraph 3, of the Dual-use regulation);
* for any of the uses
referred to above, the exporter is aware of, he must notify the
Ministry of Foreign Affairs. In such a case the exporter will be duly
notified by MFA that a license is required on the export concerned;
or
* if the purchasing
country or country of destination is subject to an arms embargo of
the EU, UN or OSCE and the items may be intended, in their entirety
or in part, for a military end-use (see article 4, paragraph 2, of
the Dual-use regulation).
In such cases the
exporter will be informed by an individual decision.
The
catch all can also be used for reasons of public safety and human
rights consideration and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, based on a
Ministerial Regulation (Verordening, artikel 8 juncto Bsg, artikel
4), can issue a ban license requirement on the export of dual-use
goods not appearing in Annex I of the Dual-use regulation (see
article Article 8 of the Dual-use regulation).(3)
The
Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) will notify the exporter that a
license is required on the concerned export. Violation of such a
catch will be penalised according to the Wet Economische Delicten
[Law on Economic Offences]. For the BES-island there is a specific
Customs Law.(5)
In the so-called
carré-overleg, every two months among and policy departments,
ongoing developments are discussed, like catch all cases. But it
limits itself to the proliferation of WMD.(6) The Catch all also has
the function to gain time to get better information and consider if
the export is or is not in line with the above mentioned
considerations more thoroughly.(7)
Although the catch all
can be used for and military end use in countries under an arms
embargo in the Netherlands is mainly used for dual use. Article 4a of
the Decision Strategic Goods provides the Minister with the powers to
prohibit extra-community transit of dual use products and trans
community transfer of dual use for WMD and military applications,(8)
based on the EU Regulation provision given for this catch all
policy.(9)
That the catch is
mainly used on dual use is to be expected, because as Anna Werter
explained the inclusion of it in the control regimes on regimes
controling WMD-weapons and the Missile Regime were necessary in order
to keep export controls up to date with rapid technological
developments and with new intelligence about possible military
applications.(10) Dennis Krepp of the National Security and
Technology Transfer Controls of the U.S. Department of Commerce
statedd in 2012 that the catch-all clauses mainly exist to to be able
to control exports that contribute to programs of concern.(11) Also
for the Dutch government catch-all is focussed on dual-use. The Dutch
government recently tried to expand the catch all in the frame work
of EC/428/2009 to ICT related technology which can be used for human
rights violations and has encouraged this in 2014 in the EU fora.(12)
The
Catch all reported
The
use of the catch-all is the most under-reported aspects of arms trade
policy. When searching the official Dutch website rechtspraak.nl
[justice.nl] on catch-all several cases verdicts and hearings are
mentioned. But they
have no connection with weapon/military related exports or point to
the same case, the exports by Slebos Research to Pakistan in
connection with the nuclear programs of his study friend Abdul Qadeer
Khan.(13) In the end Slebos was in fact not punished. He got a
suspended fine of € 85.000, but with a probation of only one day
only to show the proven crime is worthy of condemnation and for
preventive reasons.(14) After more as four years the complicated
catch-all and dual use case came to an sloppy end.
In
the annual reports on military exports, the Netherlands mentioned
catch all denials only in 2009: civil aircraft parts and civil
camouflage paint to Iran.(15) But since that time the term catch all
is mentioned only once in the 2014 report in connection to improved
catch all use in the framework of the Australia group.(16) The catch
all was also part of the annual report of the General (AIVD) and
Military (MIVD) Intelligence and Secret Service reporting, they
provided information to the Ministry of Economics, Agriculture and
Inovation (now Ministry of Economics) leading to several cases of
enforcing catch all cases.(17)
The
Catch alls are not exchanged among the member states, however one
third of the denials are connected to catch alls according a 2009
evaluation report of Dutch arms export policy.(18) In the same year
however the Minister of Economics Van Ardenne wrote to the parliament
that European exchange on catch all cases is not an established
policy, but that exchange of information on exports to Iran are more
extensively shared and evaluated among EU Member States.(19) Most
detailed Dutch information is a table provided in December 2008 on
catch alls to countries under embargo or are potentially dangerous
proliferation destinations.(20)
Datum
|
Product
|
Land
van
bestemming
|
Vergunning
aangevraagd
|
Vergunning
verleend
|
Opmerkingen
|
10/09/2008
|
Wetenschappelijke
tijdschriften
|
Iran
|
Ja, 20
stuks
|
Ja, 11
stuks
|
|
19/08/2008
|
Röntgen
diffractie apparatuur (onderdelen voor)
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
29/07/2008
|
Rotorbladen
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
12/06/2008
|
Aluminium
buizen
|
Iran en
Irak
|
Nee
|
|
|
21/05/2008
|
Ringen
|
Iran
|
|
|
Ingetrokken
|
25/04/2008
|
Werktuigmachines
(onderdelen voor)
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
01/04/2008
|
Uranium
analyse apparatuur
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
28/03/2008
|
Smeermiddel
|
Iran
|
Ja
|
Ja
|
|
27/03/2008
|
Onderhoudsapparatuur
|
Iran
|
Ja
|
Nee
|
|
25/03/2008
|
Vliegtuigonderdelen
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
26/02/2008
|
Vliegtuigonderdelen
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
13/02/2008
|
Filters
voor microdeeltjes (HEPA)
|
Iran
|
Ja
|
Ja
|
|
29/01/2008
|
Duikapparatuur
en toebehoren
|
Iran
|
Ja
|
Nee
|
|
16/01/2008
|
Gaschromatrograaf
|
Iran
|
Ja
|
Nee
|
|
02/01/2008
|
Nikkellegeringen
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
30/11/2007
|
Staal
gelegeerd met chroom en molybdeen
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
30/11/2007
|
Reinigingsmiddel
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
29/08/2007
|
Roestvrijstalen
staven
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
28/08/2007
|
Software
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
30/08/2007
|
Warmte-behandelingsoven
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
20/08/2007
|
Plasmaspuitapparatuur
|
Iran
|
Ja
|
Nee
|
|
02/08/2007
|
Fotospectrometer
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
29/01/2007
|
Vliegtuigonderdelen
|
Iran
|
Ja, 216
stuks
|
Ja, 152
stuks
|
Herzien
|
13/11/2006
|
Grondverf
|
Iran
|
Nee
|
|
|
05/10/2006
|
Vliegtuigonderdelen
|
Iran
|
|
|
Ingetrokken
|
28/09/2006
|
Vliegtuigonderdelen
|
Iran
|
|
|
Ingetrokken
|
Source:
Vaste commissie voor Economische Zaken, List of
questions and answers. Published December
5, 2008-2009, 22054, no. 143, Tweede Kamer 2008-2009,
question 2.
|
Recent
cases
One
of the more recent cases deals with the deliverance in 2003 of glycol
(MEG) from the Netherlands to Syria. The Netherlands was warned by
the US during a conversation with employees of the Ministries of
Foreign and Economic Affairs at the 7th of August 2003 that the MEG was intended for the Syrian missile
program. Belgium customs stopped the glycol in the harbour of Antwerp
and the Netherlands was
asked by the US to assist in preventing the export to sail. However
this was juridically impossible, because a treaty between the
Netherlands and Belgium of 1842 prohibited limitations on
consignments from Antwerp via De Schelde to the North Sea. The
Belgium authorities were also juridically hampered because the goods
where not on the dual-use list and because it was a Dutch export they
were not authorised to stop it by a catch all. This hole was
relatively fast repaired having glycol on a Dutch National dual use
Regulation.(21) A relatively fast solution to prevent further
exports.
In 2015 German de-militarised army trucks were
exported to Sudan (see also below). Members of Parliament Raymond
Knops (CDA) and Sjoerd Sjoerdsma both asked questions on the issue.
Knops asked if agreements with industry and trade on a small number
of sensitive destinations (like Syria, North-Korea, Sudan,
Myanmar and Iran) to prevent the export of potentially sensitive,
non-strategic goods, military used at its destination. He asked if in
this kind of agreement, without large administrative burdens, the
catch-all could be used. The answer on use of the catch-all was given
to Sjoerdsma:
“a catch all can only be enforced if the (civil)
goods which are not listed on the EU military list, but get an
military use in a country under an arms embargo. Military end use is
only the case when the (civil) goods are used for the development,
production or overhaul of goods on the EU military list,” according
to Minister Ploumen of Trade and Development Aid answered. In
this case the Netherlands considers the trucks as civil and thus not
under the catch all.(22)
(unpublished May 2016)
Footnotes:
Van
Velzen, K, Questions to the Ministers of Foreign Affairs, Justice
and secretary of Economic Affairs on the deliverance of strategic
goods to Pakistan of October 9, 2007. Published October 9, 2007,
2007-2008. Answered by Minister of Foreign Affairs Verhagen, M.J.M.
and the Secretary of Economics Heemskerk, F., also on behalve of the
Minister of Justice. Received November 7, 2007. Published March 17,
2008. 2007-2008, question 1601.
Ministry
of Foreign Affairs, Handboek Strategische Goederen en Diensten,
April 2016, p. 16.
Ministry
of Foreign Affairs, Handboek Strategische Goederen en Diensten,
April 2016, p. 16; and Handboek Veiligheid, Gezondheid, Economie en
Milieu (VGEM [Security, Health, Economy and Environment]); chapter 5
on Dual-use goods on the web site of the tax authorities
(http://www.belastingdienst.nl/bibliotheek/handboeken/html/boeken/HVGEM/strategische_goederen-goederen_voor_tweeerlei_gebruik_dual_use_.html)
Van
Velzen, K, Questions to the Ministers of Foreign Affairs, Justice
and secretary of Economic Affairs on the deliverance of strategic
goods to Pakistan of October 9, 2007. Published October 9, 2007,
2007-2008. Answered by Minister of Foreign Affairs Verhagen, M.J.M.
and the Secretary of Economics Heemskerk, F., also on behalve of the
Minister of Justice. Received November 7, 2007. Published March 17,
2008. 2007-2008, question 1601.
Besluit
van 23 december 2010 tot vaststelling van het Uitvoeringsbesluit
Douane- en Accijnswet BES (Uitvoeringsbesluit Douane- en Accijnswet
BES) Article 2.3. This article regulates the licensing for export.
Is connected to agreements in which the Netherlands is a party. The
regulation is similar to the Dutch export regulation. Also the BES
islands may use a so-called catch-all for reasons of public security
or on human rights considerations.
This
so-called carréoverleg is mentioned in Inspectie
Ontwikkelingssamenwerking en report Beleidsevaluatie,
Beleidsdoorlichting van het Nederlandse exportcontrole- en
wapenexportbeleid, IOB Evaluaties, no. 325, October 2009. Published
by Ministry of Foreign Affairs, p. 52; and Doorvoer van strategische
goederen; Het wettelijk kader en de bestuurlijke praktijk in het
Vlaamse Gewest en de naburige stelsels Kathleen Van Heuverswyn,
i.s.m. Nils Duquet, Brussel, 6 augustus 2013 (
http://www.vlaamsvredesinstituut.eu/sites/vlaamsvredesinstituut.eu/files/files/reports/rapport_doorvoer_van_strategische_goederen.pdf
Handboek
Veiligheid, Gezondheid, Economie en Milieu (VGEM [Security, Health,
Economy and Environment]); chapter 5.4.3 Catch-all regulation on
exports on the web site of the tax authorities
(http://www.belastingdienst.nl/bibliotheek/handboeken/html/boeken/HVGEM/strategische_goederen-goederen_voor_tweeerlei_gebruik_dual_use_.html)
See:
Article 4a Besluit strategische goederen (valid April 1, 2015 until
present).
Article
4(6) COUNCIL REGULATION (EC) No 428/2009 of 5 May 2009 setting
up a Community regime for the control of exports, transfer,
brokering and transit of dual-use items.
Anna
Werter, Enforcing European Union Law enforcing on exports of
dual-use goods, SIPRI Research Report no. 24, Oxford University
Press, 2009, p. 57.
Mr.
Dennis Krepp Office of National Security and Technology Transfer
Controls U.S. Department of Commerce, Powerpoint: Implementing Catch
All Controls A Risk Assessment-based Approach Toward
Nonproliferation, March 2012
(http://www.state.gov/strategictrade/documents/organization/190331.pdf,
visited May 3, 2016)
Algemene
commissie voor Buitenlandse Handel en Ontwikkelingssamenwerking.
List of questions and answers of February 11, 2016, 2015-2016,
published February 12, no. 270, 22 054, question 42.
Staatssecretaris Bleker van Economische Zaken, Landbouw en Innovatie
during Parliamentary debate stated the same on January 2012, Tweede
Kamer, vergaderjaar 2011–2012, 22 054, nr. 190 , p. 15
kst-22054-190.
See
http://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/ e.g. this one
http://deeplink.rechtspraak.nl/uitspraak?id=ECLI:NL:RBALK:2005:AU8250
and search for “catch-all.” For an overview of the operations by
Slebos see, Frank Slijper, Project Butter Factory; Henk Slebos and
the A.Q. Khan nuclear network, Transnational Institute in
association with Campagne tegen Wapenhandel, Amsterdam, September
2007.
http://deeplink.rechtspraak.nl/uitspraak?id=ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2009:BH1775
Iran
was a priority at the time, see 21501-02-961 Minister of Economic
Affairs Van Ardenne-van der Hoeven, Raad Algemene Zaken en Raad
Buitenlandse Zaken, Den Haag, 21 april 2010 Tweede Kamer 2009-2010.
Wapenexportbeleidsraporten
2004-214 searched for catch all, only two catches. Annual Report
Arms Export Policy 2014 (in Dutch), p. 14.
Ministerie
van Binnenlandse Zaken en Koninkrijksrelaties, Annual report 2010 of
Algemene Inlichtingen- en Veiligheidsdienst, april 2011, p. 30.
blg-109155; and Ministry of Defence Annual Report Arms Export Policy
2010 Militaire Inlichtingen- en Veiligheidsdienst (Annual report)
MIVD 2010 April 2011, p. 41.blg-111454.
Inspectie
Ontwikkelingssamenwerking en report Beleidsevaluatie,
Beleidsdoorlichting van het Nederlandse exportcontrole- en
wapenexportbeleid, IOB Evaluaties, no. 325, October 2009. Published
by Ministry of Foreign Affairs, p. 82.
Minister
of Economic Affairs Van Ardenne-van der Hoeven, M.J.A., Letter
Council General and Foreign Affairs, April 21, 2010. Published April
23, 2010, 2009-2010, 21501-02 no. 961.
Vaste commissie voor Economische Zaken, List of questions and answers. Published December 5, 2008-2009, 22054, no. 143, Tweede Kamer 2008-2009, question 2.
Algemene
commissie voor Buitenlandse Handel en Ontwikkelingssamenwerking en
de vaste commissie voor Buitenlandse Zaken, debate on Initiatiefnota
van de leden Sjoerdsma en Servaes: «Wapens en Principes, Ambities
voor een geloofwaardig en geharmoniseerd wapenexportbeleid in
Europa». Published on 16 september 2015, 2015-2016, 34103 no. 6;
and The algemene commissie voor Buitenlandse Handel en
Ontwikkelingssamenwerking, List of questions and answers. Published
June 20, 2014, 2013-2014, 22054, No. 246.
Sjoerdsma,
S., Question to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Development Aid
on trucks to Sudan, sent June 26 2015 and answered by Minister
Ploumen September 2, 2015 2014-2015 (3296); Knops, R., additional
questions on same issue to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and
Development Aid, sent July 1, 2015 and answered by Minister Ploumen
September 2 2015 2014-2015 (3295).